Chapter 4 - The Voice in the Box
The digital voice recorder sat in the center of the oak table in Interview Room 102.
It was nearly two in the morning. The rain outside had settled into a steady, miserable drizzle that washed down the high, narrow windows of the station, casting long, wavering shadows across the floor.
Hannah, Vance, and Assistant District Attorney Karen Brooks sat around the table. Brooks was a sharp, fifty-ish woman with short grey hair and cold brown eyes, wearing a black trench coat over her business suit. She had come straight from her home in the suburbs after Vance's midnight phone call.
Vance reached out his thick index finger and pressed the black 'Play' button on the recorder.
A high-pitched hiss of static filled the quiet room, followed by the sound of a heavy breath being drawn through a constricted throat. Then, a woman's voice came through the small speaker—clear, light, but trembling with profound exhaustion.
"My name is Sarah Vance," the recording began. "Today is September 14th. If you are listening to this tape... it means I was wrong to trust my sister."
Hannah leaned in closer, her arms crossed tightly across her chest.
"Six months ago," Sarah’s voice continued on the recording, "I started getting sick. Small things at first—dizziness, vomiting, strange fluttering sensations in my chest that made it hard to breathe. The doctors at Westbrook General thought it was stress or panic attacks brought on by the anniversary of our parents' death. But last month, I found the bottles in Claire's basement."
A long pause followed on the tape. The sound of a glass bottle clinking against wood was audible in the background, followed by a soft, wet cough.
"She's been coming to my apartment every Tuesday," Sarah said, her voice dropping to a whisper. "She brings me health smoothies. Green drinks made with kale, spinach, and apple juice. She tells me she's trying to help me get my strength back. But last week, I didn't drink the smoothie she left in my fridge. I brought it to a private lab in Boston. They found digitalis in it. A heavy dose."
ADA Brooks shook her head slowly, her jaw clenching hard. "My God."
"I confronted her yesterday," Sarah’s voice trembled on the speaker. "Not directly. I couldn't. I was too terrified. I told her I was going to the police to file a report about my trust account, because I noticed three hundred thousand dollars had been transferred out of the principal fund into an offshore holding company registered in Delaware. Claire didn't get angry. She just smiled. She gave me that cold, beautiful smile she's had since we were girls."
A heavy sigh rattled through the speaker.
"She told me I was crazy. She told me nobody would believe a woman who has spent three years in and out of psychiatric clinics for depression. She said if I went to the police, she would make sure I never saw my niece again. She knew how much I loved Lily. Lily is the only pure thing left in this family."
The recording clicked, a brief pause in the tape, as though Sarah had paused the machine to catch her breath. When the voice returned, it sounded closer to the microphone, urgent and frantic.
"I am hiding this box inside Lily's brown bear tonight while Claire is upstairs putting her to sleep. I sewed the seam myself with white yarn from my sewing kit so Lily wouldn't lose it. I told Lily that Mr. Bear was holding a special secret for Aunt Sarah, and that if anything ever happened to me—if I ever went to sleep and didn't wake up—she had to give Mr. Bear to a real police officer."
A tearful, choked sob broke through the audio.
"If you're hearing this, Claire found a way to finish it. She forced me to drink it, or she put it in my food. Please... protect Lily. Claire doesn't want the money just for herself. She needs it because Evan's business is bankrupt. They owe millions to people who don't take excuses. And if Claire realizes Lily saw her... she won't hesitate. Please. Save my little girl."
The recording ended with a sharp clack of plastic as the tape reached its end.
Silence swallowed the interview room once again.
Hannah sat frozen in her chair, her hands clenched into tight fists in her lap. The horrifying picture was finally assembling itself in her mind—piece by terrible piece.
"She used the child," Hannah whispered, her voice shaking with rage. "Claire brought the poisoned drink to Sarah's apartment. But Sarah didn't want to drink it. So Claire..."
"Claire tried to make Lily drink it," Vance finished the sentence, his face grim as granite. "Lily said her mother gave her the green cup. She told Lily to drink it. But Lily didn't like the taste—it tasted like dirt, she said—so she poured it into the houseplant behind the couch when Claire wasn't looking."
"And when Claire saw that the child hadn't drunk it," Brooks added, her voice cold as ice, "she had to kill Sarah herself. She forced Sarah to take the Secobarbital pills to cover up the digitalis, dressed her in the bathrobe to make it look like she died in her sleep, and put the yellow dress back in the closet."
"And the plant died," Hannah remembered, her throat tight. "The plant behind the couch died because of the digitalis Lily poured into the pot. That's how a three-year-old child knew the plant died 'just like Aunt Sarah'."
Vance stood up, picking up his suit jacket from the back of the chair and sliding his thick arms into the sleeves.
"Where is the child right now?" Vance asked.
"She's down in the family services room with Officer Gable," Hannah said. "She fell asleep about an hour ago on the couch."
Vance locked eyes with the Assistant District Attorney. "We have enough for a capital murder warrant against Claire Whitmore. And conspiracy against Evan."
"Issue the warrant," Brooks said without a moment's hesitation. "Arrest them both."
Vance turned toward the door, but stopped when he saw Hannah standing motionless near the table, staring at the small black voice recorder.
"Hannah?" Vance asked. "What is it?"
Hannah lifted her head slowly, her face pale beneath the harsh lights.
"Marcus," Hannah said softly. "Think about what Lily said when she first walked into the lobby tonight."
Vance frowned. "What do you mean?"
"She said her mother told her that if the police found the shiny thing inside Mr. Bear," Hannah whispered, her eyes wide with a sudden, sickening realization, "they were going to take the next aunt away too."
Vance’s brow furrowed. "The next aunt? Claire doesn't have another sister. Sarah was her only sibling."
May you like
Hannah reached for the beige file folder on the table and flipped it open with trembling fingers, scanning the family tree documents they had pulled from the county records department two hours ago.
"Claire doesn't have another sister," Hannah said, her breath catching in her throat as her finger stopped on a line of tiny print near the bottom of page four. "But Evan does."
