Chapter 3 - The Matchbook
The light rain continued to fall as Nathan stood by the high window of his study, staring out into the dark expanse of the rear lawn.
Down in the west garden, he could see a faint, flickering beam of light. It was Arthur, sixty-three years old, holding a flashlight in his teeth while his arthritic hands tried to tie wet rose branches to a wooden trellis in the middle of a gale.
Nathan pulled out his phone and dialed the house security desk.
"Sir?" answered Thomas, the night security chief stationed at the gatehouse.
"Thomas," Nathan said, his voice like gravel. "Go to the west rose garden right now. Take Arthur inside the security lodge. Get him a dry coat, a hot drink, and tell him he is off duty until Monday. If Miss Caldwell asks why he is not outside, tell her you were acting on direct orders from an unknown authority."
"Understood, Mr. Whitmore," Thomas replied instantly. "Sir... we didn't know you were back."
"No one knows I’m back," Nathan said. "Keep it that way."
He hung up.
A soft click sounded at the service door again.
Margaret Ellis stepped into the study. She had washed the wine stains from her hands, but her left thumb was tightly bandaged with white gauze. Her face was pale, her dark eyes hollowed out by fear and exhaustion.
"Mr. Whitmore," she whispered, her voice trembling. "Ruth told me you were here."
Nathan walked over to her. He didn't speak. He gently took her hand—the one with the bandaged thumb—and looked down at it.
"Does it need stitches, Margaret?" he asked quietly.
"No, sir. It’s just a scratch," she said, trying to pull her hand back out of instinctual modesty. "Mr. Whitmore, I am so sorry about the glass. It was your mother’s—"
"Stop," Nathan commanded softly. "Do not apologize to me for a glass. Ever."
He led her to a chair and made her sit down. He walked over to his private bar, poured a measure of twenty-year-old single malt scotch into a crystal tumbler, and set it in front of her.
"Drink it," he said.
Margaret looked at the amber liquid, then up at him, tears welling in her eyes. "Mr. Whitmore... she told us you knew. She told us you signed off on the paycheck cuts."
"I know what she told you," Nathan said. He pulled up a chair opposite her and sat down. "I just saw the audit. I know about the four hundred thousand dollars."
Margaret swallowed hard. She reached deep into the apron pocket of her uniform—the same apron she had been wearing when she was kneeling on the floor—and pulled out a small object wrapped in a clean paper towel.
"I found this three days ago," Margaret whispered, placing the object on the glass table between them. "I was cleaning the primary guest cottage after a visitor left. Miss Caldwell told us the guest was an interior decorator from Atlanta brought in to assess the drawing room curtains."
Nathan unwrapped the paper towel.
Inside lay a black cardboard matchbook.
Stamped across the front in metallic silver foil was a stylized, sharp-edged crown above a single word: THE CROWN CLUB.
Nathan’s jaw clenched.
The Crown Club was an exclusive, subterranean illegal gambling den and private lounge located beneath a historic hotel in downtown Atlanta. It was owned, operated, and heavily guarded by Dominic Rainer. It was where Rainer met his lieutenants, conducted high-stakes extortion deals, and entertained corrupt politicians.
A regular person didn't just walk into The Crown Club. You had to be carrying an encrypted access key, or you had to be personally vouched for by Rainer himself.
"Who was the visitor, Margaret?" Nathan asked, his tone dropping into a dangerous, rhythmic murmur.
"A man," Margaret said softly. "Tall, dark hair, short beard. He had a scar running from the corner of his left eye down to his jaw. He didn't speak to any of the staff. Miss Caldwell met him at the gate herself at eleven o'clock at night while you were away at the board meeting in Chicago last month. They stayed in the guest cottage for two hours."
A scar from his eye to his jaw.
Nathan recognized the description instantly.
Julian Vance—no relation to David Vance, the auditor—was Dominic Rainer’s chief enforcer. Julian was a psychopath who had served four years in federal prison for racketeering before Rainer pulled strings to get him paroled. He was the man Rainer used when he wanted to burn down a competitor’s warehouse or break a labor leader’s knees.
Julian Vance had been inside Nathan Whitmore’s home. Sitting in his guest cottage. Drinking his liquor. Talking to his fiancée.
"Margaret," Nathan said, his voice entirely destitute of emotion. "Did he touch anything else? Did they go into my main study?"
"No, sir," Margaret replied. "I watched the security monitors from the butler's pantry. Miss Caldwell kept him in the cottage the entire time. But when he left... he gave her an envelope. A thick, yellow manila envelope. She took it upstairs to her dressing room immediately."
Nathan stood up slowly. He picked up the black matchbook, holding it between his thumb and forefinger.
The puzzle pieces were assembling with absolute, terrifying clarity.
Victoria Caldwell hadn't met Nathan by accident at that charity gala eighteen months ago. She was the daughter of a corrupt circuit judge who was heavily indebted to Dominic Rainer’s illegal gambling operations in Atlanta. Her family’s high-society reputation was a hollow shell, propped up by Rainer’s money.
She had been placed in Nathan’s path. She had cultivated his affection, moved into his house, learned the layout of his estate, and gained access to his domestic finances.
And now, she was actively funneling money out of his household accounts while serving as an insider scout for the man who wanted to put a bullet in Nathan’s head.
And to make herself feel powerful while doing it, she had spent her days tormenting sixty-year-old gardeners and fifty-eight-year-old housekeepers who couldn't fight back.
A soft sound echoed from the heavy oak door leading to the main second-floor hallway.
The lock clicked.
The door swung open.
Victoria Caldwell walked into the library.
She was wearing a flowing robe of white Italian silk, her blonde hair damp from her bath, a glass of sparkling water in her hand. She looked radiant, poised, and utterly serene.
"Nathan?" she called out, her voice dripping with artificial sweetness as she stepped into the dim room. "I thought I heard voices down here. My god, when did you get back from New York? You didn't text—"
She stopped dead.
Her eyes flicked from Nathan, who was standing beside his desk in his dark suit...
To Margaret Ellis, sitting in the leather armchair holding a glass of twenty-year-old scotch...
To the open laptop screens glowing with financial spreadsheets and bank routing numbers...
And finally, to the black matchbook with the silver crown resting between Nathan’s fingers.
May you like
The color drained from Victoria’s face so fast it looked as if she had been struck by a physical blow. Her hand shook, the sparkling water sloshing over the brim of her glass, dripping onto her pristine white silk robe.
"Nathan..." she stammered, her voice dropping two octaves, losing every drop of its sweet polish. "What... what is this?"
