Chapter 3 - THE MISSING BLUE PENCIL
The motel was situated just off Interstate 70, a two-story concrete structure with flickering neon signage that buzzed softly against the darkening evening sky. The room smelled faintly of stale tobacco, commercial floor wax, and heavy dampness.
I paid for two nights with my personal credit card—the small, separate account I had kept since before our marriage.
Noah sat on the edge of the double bed with the floral scratchy comforter, his knees pulled up tight against his chest. His sensory overload was building rapidly. The unfamiliar smell of the room, the hum of the old air conditioning unit in the wall, and the sudden disruption of his evening routine were causing his body to rigidify.
I was sitting on the floor beside him, attempting to gently convince him that the comforter was clean and safe to touch, when my phone vibrated in my purse.
The caller ID displayed Diane Bennett.
For one foolish, desperate second, my brain yielded to a naive hope. I thought she was calling to condemn her son. I thought Eric had called her, told her what he had done, and that her maternal instincts—or at least her sense of basic human decency—had compelled her to call and help her grandson.
"Laura," Diane said as soon as I pressed the phone to my ear. Her voice was cool, measured, and stripped of all emotional warmth. "I just spoke with Eric."
"He threw us out, Diane," I said, my voice shaking for the first time that night. "He brought a woman into our home with her luggage and told us to leave."
"Let's not indulge in dramatic language, Laura," Diane said smoothly, the sound of ice clinking against glass audible over the line. "Eric didn't throw you out. He offered you space. The situation in that house has been intolerable for months, and you know it."
I couldn't speak. My throat felt as though it were closing up.
"You have turned that home into a clinic," Diane continued calmly. "Everything revolves around Noah’s conditions, Noah’s schedules, Noah’s needs. Eric has been completely marginalized in his own family. Maybe... maybe Eric just needs a chance at a normal family, Laura. Have you ever considered what he has been carrying?"
I looked up from the floor. Noah was kneeling beside his open pencil box on the floral comforter, his little fingers frantically sorting through the plastic compartments.
"Did you just say he deserves a normal family?" I whispered, the words tasting like copper in my mouth.
"Everything has become impossibly difficult, Laura," she said, ignoring my question entirely. "Eric is under an immense amount of pressure at work, and coming home to a high-stress environment night after night—"
I clicked the red button and ended the call. I didn't yell. I didn't scream into the receiver. I simply cut her off mid-sentence, pulled her contact profile up on my phone, and pressed Block.
I set the phone on the nightstand, my breathing shallow and fast.
Suddenly, Noah let out a sharp, distressed gasp. He plunged both hands into his pencil box, dumping all the colored pencils out onto the bedsheet with a loud clatter.
"Mom?" his voice was high, tight, edging dangerously close to full-blown panic.
"I'm right here, Noah. I'm right here." I stood up and knelt beside him on the bed.
"Where’s Blue?" he demanded, his hands shuffling wildly through the scattered wooden sticks. "Where is Blue?"
I looked down at the pile. Red. Yellow. Green. Brown. Purple. Orange. Two shades of black. White. Pink.
There was no blue pencil.
"Sweetie, let me check the duffel bag," I said quickly, reaching for the canvas bag on the floor. I dug through the rolled-up shirts, the socks, the medical folders. Nothing. "I... I think we left it on the kitchen table when we packed up the box, Noah. It must have rolled under your sketchbook."
"No," Noah said, his small shoulders shaking as he began to rock back and forth on his knees. "No, no, no. The set has ten. Red, yellow, green, brown, purple, orange, black, black, white, blue. Blue is missing."
"We can go to the store first thing in the morning, buddy," I pleaded gently, touching his shoulder. "We'll buy a whole new box. A bigger box. With twenty pencils."
Noah shook his head violently, tears finally spilling over his eyelashes and tracking down his flushed cheeks. "It’s not the same one. It belongs in the box. Blue belongs in the box."
That was the moment that utterly broke me.
Not Vanessa standing by my counter with her sleek silver suitcases. Not Eric telling me to pack up our lives on a Thursday afternoon. Not Diane telling me that her son deserved a "normal family."
It was a missing six-inch wooden pencil with a broken graphite tip, abandoned on a kitchen table in a beige house outside Columbus.
I stood up, walked into the cramped motel bathroom, closed the thin hollow-core door behind me, and turned on the sink faucet to drown out the noise. I covered my mouth with a hand and sobbed into the small, rough motel towels for two straight minutes until my chest ached.
Then I washed my face with freezing water, dried my skin, pulled my hair back into a tight ponytail, and walked back out into the room.
May you like
Noah was lying sideways on the bed, his knees drawn up to his chest, staring intently at the nine remaining colored pencils lined up in a neat, perfect row on the floral comforter.
I laid down beside him, pulled his small body close to mine, wrapped my arms around him, and didn't close my eyes for the rest of the night.
