Chapter 7 - The Trial of Diane Vance
Two months later.
The County Superior Courthouse was packed to capacity for the trial of State of Arizona v. Diane Marie Vance.
Media crews were lined up along the steps outside, captivated by the sensational story of a wealthy suburban matriarch caught on 4K camera beating her daughter-in-law while her daughter drilled into a safe.
I sat in the front row of the gallery beside Ethan, wearing a sharp navy suit. My face had fully healed, leaving no physical trace of the bruises, though the memory remained as sharp as broken glass.
Across the courtroom, sitting at the defense table, was Diane.
She was dressed in a plain, oversized grey prison uniform. Her silver hair was unstyled, her face deeply lined with stress, and her eyes darted frantically around the courtroom like a cornered animal. Beside her sat her court-appointed public defender, looking thoroughly overwhelmed by the mountain of evidence stacked against his client.
Vanessa and Marcus were absent—both having already accepted guilty plea bargains, awaiting their own sentencing hearings in federal facility custody.
The prosecutor stood before the jury box, holding a remote control.
“Ladies and gentlemen of the jury,” the prosecutor began, his voice echoing through the silent courtroom. “The defense will try to tell you that this was a unfortunate family dispute. They will try to tell you that Diane Vance was merely a concerned mother trying to recover personal items.”
The prosecutor pressed a button on the remote.
The grand courtroom projection screens descended from the ceiling, lighting up with the crystal-clear, high-definition security footage from my master bedroom.
The jury gasped as the audio filled the room.
“Scream louder!” Diane’s recorded voice hissed through the courtroom speakers, raw, brutal, and sadistic.
The video showed the physical assault in agonizing detail: the hard slap, the violent hair-pulling, the shove to the floor, and Vanessa’s cold laughter from inside the closet as the drill whined against the steel safe.
I saw several jurors cover their mouths in horror. Two of them turned their heads away from the screen, visibly sickened by the cruelty on display.
Diane lowered her head onto the defense table, trying to cover her ears, but her attorney forcefully pulled her hands down, whispering to her to face the jury.
Next, the prosecutor called Ethan to the witness stand.
Ethan walked up to the stand with a calm, dignified posture, taking the oath without hesitation.
“Mr. Vance,” the prosecutor asked, stepping toward the witness box. “Can you describe your relationship with your mother prior to the morning of October 14th?”
“I believed she was a loving, albeit demanding, mother,” Ethan testified, his voice clear and resonant. “I spent my entire adult life trying to help her, supporting my siblings financially, and believing that family was the most important thing in the world.”
“And what do you believe now, Mr. Vance?”
Ethan turned his eyes directly toward Diane, looking at her with absolute clarity.
“I know now that she is a master manipulator who viewed my wife and me as nothing more than financial targets to be exploited. The woman sitting at that table is a cold-blooded criminal who was willing to destroy my life and murder my wife’s dignity for money.”
Diane suddenly burst into hysterical, frantic weeping from the defense table. “Ethan! How can you say that about your own mother?! I raised you! I loved you!”
“Order in the court!” the judge slammed his gavel down sharply. “Mrs. Vance, one more outburst from you and I will have you removed to a holding cell for the remainder of this testimony!”
Diane sank back into her chair, clutching her tissue, her face red and distorted with pure rage.
Ethan didn't look back at her. He finished his testimony smoothly, answering every question with unwavering precision.
When the cross-examination began, the public defender attempted to push Ethan on whether he had ever given his mother verbal permission to access the house.
May you like
“Never,” Ethan replied instantly. “My wife holds the sole deed to the property. My mother was explicitly told weeks prior that she was not welcome in our home without a prior invitation.”
By the end of the day, the prosecution rested its case. The defense didn't even call a single witness. The evidence was so absolute, so overwhelming, that any defense attempt was akin to standing against a tidal wave.
